Local News
U.S. Supreme Court rules against Mohawk in attorney-client privilege case
The U.S. Supreme Court agreed on Tuesday that a federal judge’s decision releasing documents created by Mohawk Industries’ lawyer could not be immediately appealed. It was Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s first opinion as a Supreme Court justice.
The case, Mohawk Industries vs. Carpenter (08-678), concerned a question of whether a lower court’s decision on attorney-client privilege can be immediately appealed to a higher court.
Norman Carpenter, a former shift supervisor at the Union Grove Road plant in Calhoun, sued Mohawk for wrongful termination after meeting with the company’s lawyer, who was also involved in litigation on an undocumented workers lawsuit against Mohawk. Carpenter, in his suit, wanted the documentation from his meeting with Mohawk’s lawyer.
While the federal judge agreed that the documents were protected by attorney-client privilege, the judge said Mohawk had waived its privilege through its disclosures in the undocumented workers litigation.
The Supreme Court agreed that the federal judge’s decision releasing documents created by Mohawk Industries’ lawyer could not be immediately appealed. “Postjudgment appeals, together with other review mechanisms, suffice to protect the rights of litigants and preserve the vitality of the attorney-client privilege,” Sotomayor said.
The judgment of the court was unanimous. Justice Clarence Thomas concurred with the judgment but disagreed with part of Sotomayor’s analysis.
Dalton attorney Matthew Thames is representing the former and current Mohawk employees who sued the company in the undocumented workers lawsuit, claiming Mohawk suppressed their wages by hiring illegal workers. Thames said he spent Tuesday in court in Lafayette and had not seen a copy of the opinion.
“I don’t know what effect it will have (on our suit), if any, without looking at the body of the case,” Thames said. He added that the undocumented workers lawsuit is currently back in U.S. District Court.
“We’re getting ready to go through the issue of the certification of class again,” he said, referring to the goal of getting a class action suit against Mohawk. “Part of that process is certifying the class, to see if it meets the prerequisite of a class action suit.”
The publisher of a magazine that covers the flooring industry said the decision didn’t throw much light on the subject.
“It sounds like the ruling is about a technicality,” said Kemp Harr of Floor Focus magazine (www.floordaily.net).
“You’re asking a businessman, not an attorney,” he said. “I just spent four days with Mohawk last week — meeting with them, helping to grow their business. They’re a great company, and it sounds like the only people getting rich off this are the lawyers. I looked at (the decision), and it’s not telling me anything and doesn’t look like it’s solving any problems.”
Brian Anderson, president and CEO of the Dalton-Whitfield Chamber of Commerce, also said it appeared the ruling was “a technical issue.”
“It may have an effect long term, but I’m not an attorney,” he said. “I don’t know if this one case speaks to the future of our employee base, and I don’t know enough about the positions of both sides to comment on the case itself.”
A phone message left with Mohawk’s legal office was not immediately returned.
- Local News
-
-
New Hope Middle awarded recycling cart
Recycling Ben, mascot for the Target Recycling program, presented the seventh-grade class at New Hope Middle School an award for having the highest recycling rate during the second quarter of the 2009-2010 school year.
-
Brochu: ‘They came to me and recruited me’
Whitfield County Schools Superintendent Katie Brochu didn’t apply to become superintendent of a South Carolina school district — she was recruited there, she said.
-
Murray high schools reach field use agreement
John Raley is not happy North Murray High School is being charged $200 per baseball game to play at Appalachian Community Bank Stadium, Murray County High School’s home field.
-
Dalton native earns Seabee honor
Cynthia Pendley said she and her family were “shocked” when her brother, David Akins, came home and told them he had enlisted in the Navy at age 19.
-
Name not released by Whitfield school system
The Whitfield County Board of Education is scheduled to hold a public hearing Thursday under the Georgia Fair Dismissal Act.
-
Residents wary of scams
Dalton Police cited two men on Wednesday for trying to sell magazine subscriptions for troops deployed overseas without a city license.
-
Dawn seeks to change guilty plea
A personal care home manager who was sentenced to prison for stealing drugs from senior residents has asked for a hearing to change his plea to not guilty.
-
Stephens says voters are concerned about future
Voters are very concerned “and even a little bit scared” about where the United States is going as a country, says former Georgia Senate Majority Leader Bill Stephens.
-
DPD looks for “hot” wheels
The Dalton Police Department is asking for the public’s help in locating and identifying a thief who stole a set of Ballistic-brand wheels worth $3,000 from the bed of the owner’s truck on March 3.
-
Habitat groundbreaking Saturday
The groundbreaking ceremony will take place at 1791 Carter Drive on Saturday at 9 a.m. to launch the building of a home for the Edgar Gutierrez family. The George R. Johnson Foundation is sponsor for the building of this house.
- More Local News Headlines
-
